Accessibility links

Breaking News

The AP And CNN Report On Tait/Nuaimi Detainment

In an Associated Press (AP) article entitled ‘Watchdog: Egyptian Military Oppressing Journalists,’ Paul Schemm dedicates much of the piece to the experiences of RFE correspondents Robert Tait and Abdelilah Nuaimi while detained in Egypt. Schemm summarizes Tait’s recent firsthand account as published by RFE on February 8. The article is reprinted in full below.

Additionally, the incident was analyzed on CNN’s Anderson Cooper 360. Tait joined the New York-based broadcast via Skype and described the disturbing incident in detail. See the full clip via the above link.

Watchdog: Egyptian Military Oppressing Journalists

Paul Schemm | Associated Press

February 8, 2011

CAIRO – Egypt's military was not allowing foreign journalists to enter Cairo's Tahrir Square on Tuesday, part of what an international press watchdog called new obstacles in covering the ongoing crisis.

Egypt's police has long played a role in the targeting of foreign and local journalists, especially over the past weeks of unrest, but the military was believed not to be involved.

Hundreds of thousands of Egyptians have been demonstrating in downtown Cairo, calling for the ouster of authoritarian President Hosni Mubarak. Journalists from all over the world had been mingling among them until Tuesday.

The government issued new orders requiring visiting journalists get accreditation from the Ministry of Information, a process that takes days, preventing many from covering the demonstrations.

Foreign journalists already with credentials were allowed into the square. Some reporters without Egyptian accreditation still managed to enter Tahrir despite the new policy.

The Committee to Protect Journalists says the military has been increasingly involved in interfering with reporters' work.

"The sudden change in policy regarding press credentials is simply the latest effort to restrict the work of journalists, many of whom have already been beaten by mobs and detained by authorities," Joel Simon, the group's executive director, said in a statement.

"The military has become the predominant force detaining journalists and confiscating their equipment rather than plainclothes police or government supporters," it added.

In the past few days, a number of journalists, including two from the English-language Al-Jazeera news channel, have been detained by military intelligence for hours.

Rosa Mollo, the Middle East correspondent for Spain's TVE station, said she and her crew were prevented from entering the square Tuesday morning, despite assurances from the press center that they would be allowed in while their new credentials were being processed.

"At the first checkpoint, the military guy told me we have clear orders today that journalists must have accreditation because we have found several foreign spies inside and the media has been distorting the facts," she said.

On Tuesday, one journalist, Robert Tait of Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, published an account of his 27-hour detention by Egypt's secret police during which he heard numerous cases of torture and abuse carried out around him. Tait was detained along with his colleague Abdelilah Nuaimi and a local assistant on Feb. 4.

While Tait and Nuaimi — both of whom hold British citizenship — were unharmed, Tait said he was blindfolded the entire time and could hear people being beaten and shocked with electrodes.

"In this hotel, we only have two things on the menu for those who don't behave — electrocution and rape," Tait said he and Nuaimi heard the jailers tell their fellow detainees.

Tait's captors later told him he was held due to the "emergency."

Tait, Nuaimi and their assistant were eventually released, and Tait and Nuaimi were taken to the airport, and put on the next flight out of Egypt.

Since Jan. 30, CPJ said there have been at least 140 direct attacks on journalists trying to cover the ongoing unrest in Egypt.